Menu Engineering: The Matrix of Stars, Plowhorses, Puzzles and Dogs
Menu engineering sorts every menu item by how often it sells and how much it earns. Here is the standard method, the two thresholds and a worked eight-item example.
Photo by Jari Hytönen on Unsplash
Menu engineering is a method for analysing a menu by two measures for each item: popularity (how many are sold) and profitability (the contribution margin, which is price minus food cost). Each item is then classed as a Star, Plowhorse, Puzzle or Dog, and that class tells you whether to promote, reprice, rework or remove it.
This guide explains the standard menu engineering matrix step by step, works through an eight-item example you can check with a calculator, and shows what to do with each group.
What is menu engineering?
Menu engineering is the practice of using sales and cost data to decide what goes on a menu, at what price and in what position. It was developed by Michael L. Kasavana and Donald I. Smith at Michigan State University's School of Hospitality Business around 1982, as Kasavana recounts in an article for the American Hotel & Lodging Educational Institute (2025). He describes the analysis as centring on three data elements: customer demand, menu mix and contribution margin.
The idea that sets restaurant menu engineering apart from older methods is that it ranks items by dollars of margin, not by food cost percentage. A steak with a 42% food cost can put more money in the bank per sale than a salad with a 25% food cost. You deposit dollars, not percentages.
What is the menu engineering matrix?
The menu engineering matrix is a two-by-two grid with popularity on one axis and contribution margin on the other. Every item lands in one of four boxes.
| High contribution margin | Low contribution margin | |
|---|---|---|
| High popularity | Star: sells well and earns well | Plowhorse: sells well, earns little per sale |
| Low popularity | Puzzle: earns well, sells rarely | Dog: sells rarely and earns little |
"High" and "low" are not judged against an industry number. Both are measured against the rest of your own menu, which is why the method works for a taco truck and a steakhouse alike.
How do I classify each item?
Classify each item by comparing its menu mix to a popularity threshold and its contribution margin to the menu's average. You need three numbers per item for a set period: units sold, menu price and plate cost.
Step 1. Choose a period and a category. Use at least four weeks of sales so one busy weekend does not distort the result. Analyse like with like: entrees against entrees, appetizers against appetizers. Mixing a $4 side with a $30 entree makes the averages meaningless.
Step 2. Calculate each item's contribution margin.
Contribution margin = menu price - plate cost
Plate cost is the cost of every ingredient in the dish as served, including garnish, sauce and bread. The food cost calculator helps build it.
Step 3. Calculate each item's menu mix.
Menu mix % = units of the item sold / total units sold in the category
Step 4. Set the popularity threshold with the 70% rule.
Popularity threshold = (1 / number of items) x 70%
On an eight-item menu an equal share would be 12.5% each. Expecting every item to reach a full equal share is unrealistic, so the method counts an item as popular if it reaches 70% of that share: 8.75%. On a ten-item menu the threshold is 7%.
Step 5. Set the profitability threshold.
Average contribution margin = total contribution margin of all items sold / total units sold
This is a weighted average: it reflects what you actually sold. Some guides use a simple average of the items' margins instead (add them and divide by the number of items), as meez describes. The weighted version is the one in the standard method as it is usually summarised, including in the Wikipedia entry on menu engineering, and it is the one our calculator uses. The two usually agree on all but borderline items.
Step 6. Classify. At or above both thresholds is a Star. Popular but below the average margin is a Plowhorse. Above the average margin but below the popularity threshold is a Puzzle. Below both is a Dog.
Worked example: an eight-item entree menu
The figures below are invented for illustration. They cover four weeks and 1,000 entrees sold.
| Item | Sold | Price | Plate cost | Margin per item | Total margin | Menu mix | Food cost % |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cheeseburger | 210 | $14.00 | $4.90 | $9.10 | $1,911 | 21% | 35.0% |
| Chicken sandwich | 180 | $13.00 | $3.90 | $9.10 | $1,638 | 18% | 30.0% |
| Fish tacos | 150 | $15.00 | $4.50 | $10.50 | $1,575 | 15% | 30.0% |
| Pasta primavera | 140 | $14.00 | $3.00 | $11.00 | $1,540 | 14% | 21.4% |
| Caesar salad | 120 | $11.00 | $2.80 | $8.20 | $984 | 12% | 25.5% |
| Salmon bowl | 80 | $19.00 | $7.00 | $12.00 | $960 | 8% | 36.8% |
| Steak frites | 60 | $26.00 | $11.00 | $15.00 | $900 | 6% | 42.3% |
| Veggie wrap | 60 | $10.00 | $3.20 | $6.80 | $408 | 6% | 32.0% |
| Total | 1,000 | $9,916 | 100% |
The thresholds:
- Popularity: (1 / 8) x 70% = 8.75%, which is 87.5 units out of 1,000.
- Profitability: $9,916 / 1,000 = $9.92 average contribution margin.
The result:
| Item | Menu mix vs 8.75% | Margin vs $9.92 | Class |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fish tacos | High (15%) | High ($10.50) | Star |
| Pasta primavera | High (14%) | High ($11.00) | Star |
| Cheeseburger | High (21%) | Low ($9.10) | Plowhorse |
| Chicken sandwich | High (18%) | Low ($9.10) | Plowhorse |
| Caesar salad | High (12%) | Low ($8.20) | Plowhorse |
| Salmon bowl | Low (8%) | High ($12.00) | Puzzle |
| Steak frites | Low (6%) | High ($15.00) | Puzzle |
| Veggie wrap | Low (6%) | Low ($6.80) | Dog |
Look at the food cost column against the result. The steak frites has the worst food cost percentage on the menu, 42.3%, and the best margin, $15.00. The Caesar salad has one of the best food cost percentages, 25.5%, and one of the lowest margins. An owner managing by food cost percentage alone would push the salad and question the steak, and would earn less.
To run this on your own menu, enter your items in the free menu profit calculator. It applies the same 70% rule and weighted average margin and sorts your items into the four classes.
What should I do with Stars and Puzzles?
Protect Stars and sell more Puzzles. Both already earn more than average per sale, so the work is about volume and visibility.
Stars (fish tacos, pasta primavera):
- Keep the recipe, portion and quality consistent.
- Give them the best positions on the menu and on the online ordering page.
- Test a small price increase. Popular items can often carry one.
- Never let them run out.
Puzzles (salmon bowl, steak frites):
- Move them to a more visible spot and rewrite the description.
- Add a photo online.
- Ask staff to recommend them and feature them as a special.
- Check the price: a Puzzle may be unpopular because it is priced above what your customers expect to pay.
- If nothing lifts sales and the item needs unique ingredients, consider removing it.
The arithmetic shows the prize. If better placement moves 30 orders a period from the veggie wrap to the steak frites, margin rises by 30 x $15.00 minus 30 x $6.80, which is $246, with the same number of customers.
What should I do with Plowhorses and Dogs?
Raise the margin on Plowhorses without scaring off the people who order them, and remove or rework Dogs.
Plowhorses (cheeseburger, chicken sandwich, Caesar salad):
- Raise the price in small steps. In the example, 50 cents on the cheeseburger adds 210 x $0.50 = $105 a period if volume holds.
- Reduce the plate cost: review the portion, the supplier and the side that comes with it.
- Pair them with higher-margin add-ons such as bacon, avocado, a premium side or a drink.
- Do not give them the best menu positions. They sell without help.
- Do not remove them. Plowhorses bring people in.
Dogs (veggie wrap):
- Remove the item, unless it has a job. The only vegetarian entree, a children's dish or a signature with a loyal following may earn its place another way.
- If it stays, reprice it or rebuild it from ingredients you already stock so it costs nothing extra to carry.
- Do not promote it.
After each change, wait a full period and run the numbers again. Moving one item changes the averages for all of them. The menu pricing calculator helps test a new price before you print it.
What data do I need from my POS?
You need the number of each item sold in the period, by category, and the price actually charged. Plate cost does not come from the POS. It comes from your recipes and supplier invoices.
| Data | Where it comes from |
|---|---|
| Units sold per item, per period | POS item sales report |
| Menu price | POS or the menu |
| Discounts and comps on the item | POS |
| Sales by channel (dine-in, online, delivery) | POS and ordering system |
| Plate cost per item | Recipe costing from invoices |
Two practical points. Count modifiers that change the cost, such as extra protein, or your margins will look better than they are. And if you sell through several systems, combine the counts first, because an item can be a Star online and a Puzzle in the dining room.
Do I need menu engineering software or a worksheet?
No. A menu engineering worksheet is a spreadsheet with one row per item and seven columns: units sold, price, plate cost, contribution margin, total margin, menu mix and class. The eight-row table above is a complete worksheet. Menu engineering software does the same calculation automatically from POS and inventory data, which saves time on large menus and menus that change often.
For most independent restaurants, a spreadsheet or the free menu profit calculator a few times a year is enough. What matters is that the sales counts are accurate and all in one place.
RestauNax helps with that part: in-store, online and app orders run through one menu, and the analytics include a menu item sales report you can export for any date range, so the units-sold column comes from a single source. It is $99/month per location; card payments are 2.9% + 30¢. Book a free demo to see it.
How often should I run a menu engineering analysis?
Run it whenever you are about to reprint the menu, and at least a few times a year. Also run it after a supplier price rise on a key ingredient, after a price change of your own, and when you add or remove several items. Seasonal menus should be analysed season against season, not against the full year.
Menu engineering FAQ
What are the four categories in menu engineering?
Stars (popular and high margin), Plowhorses (popular and low margin), Puzzles (unpopular and high margin) and Dogs (unpopular and low margin). Each item is classed against the other items on the same menu.
What is the 70% rule in menu engineering?
It is the popularity test. An item counts as popular if its share of sales is at least 70% of an equal share. With 10 items, an equal share is 10%, so the threshold is 7%. With 8 items it is 8.75%.
Is menu engineering based on food cost percentage?
No. It is based on contribution margin in dollars. Food cost percentage is still worth tracking for the whole operation, as part of prime cost, but a low percentage does not make an item profitable.
How is contribution margin calculated?
Contribution margin is the menu price minus the item's direct food cost. A $15.00 dish with a $4.50 plate cost has a $10.50 contribution margin. Labor and overhead are not deducted at item level in the standard method.
Does menu engineering work for online ordering menus?
Yes, and it is easier to act on. You can reorder items, change photos and descriptions, and feature a Puzzle at the top of a category without reprinting anything. Analyse online sales separately, because the mix often differs from dine-in.
Sources
- Michael L. Kasavana, "The Power of Menu Engineering - Part One", American Hotel & Lodging Educational Institute (April 8, 2025)
- meez, "Menu Engineering Matrix" (threshold formulas)
- Wikipedia, "Menu engineering" (summary of the Kasavana and Smith method), checked November 14, 2026
Tags:
About the Author
RestauNax
The team building RestauNax, writing about restaurant technology and the real cost of third-party delivery.