In-House Delivery vs Third-Party Delivery vs On-Demand Couriers: Which Fits Your Restaurant?
Your own drivers, a delivery app, or an on-demand courier on your own website. We compare the three delivery models on cost per order, control and customer ownership, with arithmetic you can check.
Photo by Charles Puaud on Unsplash
In-House Delivery vs Third-Party Delivery vs On-Demand Couriers: Which Fits Your Restaurant?
In-house delivery vs third-party delivery comes down to who employs the driver and who owns the customer. With in-house delivery you pay drivers and keep the customer. With a third-party app you pay 15% to 30% commission and the app keeps the customer. On-demand couriers are the third model: your own orders, someone else's driver, a flat fee per trip.
Most comparisons stop at two options. This one covers all three, because the third is how many independent restaurants now deliver without hiring anyone.
Disclosure: this article is published by RestauNax, which sells restaurant software. We are one of the options below, so read our entry with that in mind.
What is the difference between first-party and third-party delivery?
First-party delivery means the customer orders from the restaurant, on its website, app or phone line. Third-party delivery means the customer orders from a marketplace such as DoorDash, Uber Eats or Grubhub, and the marketplace passes the order to the restaurant.
The difference is about the order, not the driver. That is why there are three models, not two:
| Model | Where the customer orders | Who drives | Who keeps the customer's details |
|---|---|---|---|
| In-house (self-delivery) | Your website, app or phone | Your employees | You |
| Third-party marketplace | The delivery app | The app's couriers | The app |
| On-demand couriers (white-label delivery) | Your website or app | A courier network, requested per order | You |
DoorDash and DoorDash Drive show the split inside one company. DoorDash Marketplace is the app where customers find you and order. DoorDash Drive sends a Dasher to deliver an order the customer placed on your own channel. Uber does the same with Uber Eats and Uber Direct.
What does in-house delivery really cost?
In-house delivery costs driver wages, vehicle costs, insurance and the time nobody is delivering. There is no commission, but the cost per order rises sharply when orders are slow.
A worked example, with assumptions you should replace with your own:
- Driver pay of $15.00 an hour, including what you pay on top of tips
- 2.5 deliveries per driver hour on a normal night
- A 6-mile round trip per delivery
- Vehicle cost at the IRS business mileage rate, which is 76 cents a mile for July to December 2026
Labor is $15.00 / 2.5 = $6.00 per delivery. Vehicle cost is 6 x $0.76 = $4.56. That is $10.56 per delivery before insurance, and before the hours when a driver is on the clock with nothing to carry. On a slow Tuesday at one delivery an hour, the same driver costs $15.00 + $4.56 = $19.56 per delivery.
Other things to price:
- Wages. Federal law lets an employer pay a tipped employee a cash wage of $2.13 an hour if tips bring the total to the $7.25 federal minimum, according to the U.S. Department of Labor. Many states set higher minimums or do not allow a tip credit, so check your state labor department.
- Insurance. A driver's personal auto policy often excludes business use. Ask your agent about hired and non-owned auto coverage before the first delivery.
- Management. Scheduling, no-shows, cash handling, and a manager driving when someone calls out.
This is general information, not legal or insurance advice.
In-house delivery works best when volume is steady and dense: a pizzeria doing 60 deliveries on a Friday inside a three-mile radius can get the cost per delivery well below a courier's fee.
When do third-party apps make sense?
Third-party apps make sense when you need new customers more than you need margin on each order. The app is a marketing channel that happens to deliver.
Published commission rates, checked November 14, 2026:
| Marketplace | Delivery commission | Pickup |
|---|---|---|
| DoorDash | 15%, 25% or 30% | 6% |
| Uber Eats | 20%, 25% or 30% | 7% |
| Grubhub | 5%, 15% or 20% marketing commission, plus delivery from 10% | See Grubhub |
On a $30 order, 30% is $9.00 and 15% is $4.50. The lower-priced plans include less, so read what each plan covers on the marketplace's own page.
Apps make sense when:
- You are new, or in a location with little foot traffic, and people search the apps for your cuisine.
- Your food cost and prices leave room for the commission. See is DoorDash worth it.
- You treat it as acquisition, and work to bring those customers back through your own channel.
They make less sense for regulars who already know your name. Paying 30% on an order from someone who has ordered from you twenty times is paying for marketing you no longer need.
What is on-demand (white-label) delivery?
On-demand delivery, also called white-label delivery, is a courier requested for one order at a time. The customer orders on your website or app, your system asks a courier network for a driver, and the driver delivers under your name. You pay a flat fee per trip and no commission on the food.
Published prices we checked on November 14, 2026:
| Service | Published price | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Uber Direct | From $7.99 per delivery | Uber says rates vary with distance, speed and market |
| DoorDash Drive | $6.99 to $10.99 per delivery | No commission; customer tips go to the Dasher |
| ChowNow Flex Delivery | $7.98 per order | Used with ChowNow ordering |
| Slice Flex Delivery | From $6.90 per order | Used with Slice ordering |
Most restaurants charge the guest a delivery fee that covers the courier. On a $30 order with an $8.00 courier fee paid by the guest, the restaurant's delivery cost is $0 plus card processing, against $9.00 at a 30% commission.
The trade-offs are real:
- No discovery. Nobody finds you through a courier network. You have to bring the customer to your own site.
- Less control at the door. The driver is not your employee, so you cannot train them.
- Fees vary by distance. A far address costs more, which is why a delivery radius matters.
- Coverage. Courier networks are strongest in cities and suburbs.
Is DoorDash Drive cheaper than using my own drivers?
It depends on your volume per hour. At the example above, an in-house delivery costs $10.56, which is close to the top of DoorDash Drive's published $6.99 to $10.99 range. If your drivers average four deliveries an hour, in-house drops to $3.75 + $4.56 = $8.31. If they average one, it is $19.56. A courier costs the same per trip whether the night is busy or dead, so couriers win on slow shifts and your own drivers win on reliably busy ones.
Should my pizzeria go third-party only instead of running our own drivers?
Usually not third-party only. Going marketplace-only removes driver costs, but it moves every delivery customer, including your regulars, to a channel that charges 15% to 30% and keeps their contact details. A safer change is to replace your own drivers with on-demand couriers on your own ordering, and keep the apps for discovery. You lose the driver payroll without giving up the customer.
Is it better to build my own ordering site or stay on delivery apps?
Do both, for different customers. Keep the apps for people who do not know you yet, and send everyone else to your own site, where an order costs card processing and a subscription instead of a commission. Put your own ordering link on your Google Business Profile, your receipts, your bags and your social profiles. Our guide to fixing delivery losses covers how to move regulars across.
Can I run a hybrid model?
Yes, and most restaurants that deliver well do. Common hybrids:
- Apps for discovery, couriers for direct. Marketplace listings stay on, and your website and app dispatch on-demand couriers.
- Own drivers at peak, couriers off-peak. Staff Friday and Saturday dinner, and let a courier network cover lunch and weeknights.
- Self-delivery on the marketplace. Uber Eats lists a 15% rate for orders you deliver with your own drivers.
The rule for any hybrid: one menu and one kitchen queue. If each channel has its own tablet and its own menu, you pay for the savings in mistakes.
How do refunds work for on-demand delivery orders?
On a first-party order you issue the refund, because you took the payment. Refund the food from your own ordering system, and raise late or failed deliveries with the courier service under its own policy for the delivery fee. Write down the delivery's tracking details when a guest complains, since the courier service will ask for them. On a marketplace order the app handles the customer and decides the refund, and you dispute charges through the app's merchant portal.
Where RestauNax fits
RestauNax uses the third model. Commission-free delivery is part of the $99/month per location plan: customers order on your website or app, a courier from a national network is requested automatically, the customer sees and pays the delivery fee for their address, and RestauNax takes 0% commission. Card payments cost 2.9% + $0.30. The delivery order sits in the same kitchen queue and customer list as every other order. RestauNax does not dispatch a restaurant's own drivers today, so ask on a demo if you want to use your own drivers. Book a free demo to see an order go from your site to a courier.
Frequently Asked Questions
Self-delivery vs third-party delivery: which is better for a restaurant?
Self-delivery is better on margin and customer ownership when you have steady, dense volume. Third-party delivery is better for reach when you need new customers. On-demand couriers sit between them: your own orders with no drivers on payroll.
What is white-label delivery?
White-label delivery is a courier service that delivers orders placed on your own website or app, under your brand, for a flat fee per trip. Uber Direct and DoorDash Drive are the best-known examples.
How much do delivery apps charge restaurants?
On published rates, DoorDash charges 15%, 25% or 30% on delivery and 6% on pickup; Uber Eats charges 20%, 25% or 30%; Grubhub charges a 5%, 15% or 20% marketing commission plus delivery from 10%.
Do I need insurance for my own delivery drivers?
Almost certainly. Personal auto policies often exclude deliveries, and the restaurant can be liable for an accident on a delivery. Ask your insurance agent about hired and non-owned auto coverage. This is general information, not advice.
Who pays the delivery fee with on-demand couriers?
Usually the guest, as a delivery fee shown at checkout. The restaurant pays it when it offers free delivery. Set a minimum order for any free-delivery offer so a small order cannot cost you more than it earns.
Can I use on-demand couriers and delivery apps at the same time?
Yes. They do not conflict. The apps handle orders placed in the apps, and the courier network handles orders placed on your own channels.
Tags:
About the Author
RestauNax
The team building RestauNax, writing about restaurant technology and the real cost of third-party delivery.