Do Restaurants Need an App? App vs Mobile Website, Honestly
Every restaurant needs a mobile website that takes orders. An app is worth adding when you have regulars who order often. Here is how to tell which side of the line you are on.
Photo by Vitaly Gariev on Unsplash
Do Restaurants Need an App? App vs Mobile Website, Honestly
Do restaurants need an app? Not every restaurant does. Every restaurant needs a mobile website that takes orders, because that is where new customers arrive. A branded app is worth adding when you have regulars who order often, since an app makes reordering faster and lets you reach them with free notifications.
The honest answer depends on how often the same people order from you. This guide gives you a way to decide, the real costs, and the reasons restaurant apps fail.
Does every successful restaurant need a mobile app?
No. Plenty of successful restaurants have no app, and some should not build one. An app helps repeat ordering. It does nothing for a guest who has never heard of you, because nobody downloads an app for a restaurant they have not tried.
A restaurant app tends to pay off when:
- Guests order often. Coffee, pizza, lunch spots, takeout-heavy kitchens.
- You have a loyalty program. Points and rewards give people a reason to keep the app.
- A good share of sales is pickup or delivery. The app shortens a task guests already do.
- You can promote it. At the counter, on bags and on receipts.
It tends not to pay off when:
- Guests visit a few times a year, as at a special-occasion restaurant
- Almost all sales are dine-in with no ordering ahead
- The app would be the only place to order, with no website behind it
Restaurant app vs mobile website: which is better?
Neither is better overall. They do different jobs, and the strongest setup uses both from one menu.
| Mobile website | Branded app | |
|---|---|---|
| Found through Google | Yes | No |
| Needs a download | No | Yes |
| First-time customers | Best | Poor |
| Repeat orders | Good | Best: saved details and reorder |
| Reaching customers | Email and text | Push notifications, plus email and text |
| Presence on the phone | A bookmark at most | Your icon on the home screen |
| Cost to maintain | Hosting and updates | App-store accounts and updates |
What are the pros and cons of a website versus an app for a restaurant?
A website's strengths are reach and zero friction: anyone can open it from a search, a QR code or a link. Its weakness is that guests leave and may not come back the same way. An app's strengths are speed for regulars, saved payment and addresses, loyalty in the guest's pocket, and push notifications. Its weaknesses are the download step and the upkeep.
Do restaurants still need a good website if they already have an app?
Yes. The website is how people find you and place a first order, and it is where the link to your app lives. An app without a website has no front door. See should my restaurant have its own website.
Is a branded mobile app worth it for my restaurant?
A branded app is worth it when the orders it moves from delivery apps to your own channel, and the extra visits it brings, are worth more than it costs. You can estimate that before you spend anything.
What an app costs. If you publish under your own name, Apple charges $99 a year for its developer program and Google Play charges a one-time $25 registration fee. On top of that is the app itself. A custom build by an agency is a large project with ongoing maintenance. An app from a restaurant software vendor is usually a monthly fee or part of a plan. Among vendors that publish a price, UpMenu lists its mobile app module at $49 a month per location, and ChowNow lists Apple's $99 yearly fee as an extra on its plans. More in how much a restaurant app costs.
A worked example. Suppose 150 of your regulars each place two orders a month through a delivery marketplace at $28 an order, and you pay 25% commission.
- Marketplace: 300 orders x $28 = $8,400 in sales, and $8,400 x 25% = $2,100 in commission.
- If half of those orders move to your own app at a card rate of 2.9% + 30¢: 150 orders x $28 = $4,200, costing $121.80 + $45.00 = $166.80 in card processing, against $1,050 in commission on the same orders.
That is about $883 a month before the cost of the app, in this example. The assumption doing the work is "half of those orders move". If you cannot get regulars to switch, the saving does not happen. Published marketplace rates are in what percentage delivery apps take.
Why do restaurant apps fail?
Restaurant apps fail because too few people download them, or because people download them and have no reason to open them again. The usual causes:
- No reason to install. "Download our app" is not a reason. A free item on the first app order is.
- Nobody mentions it. Staff do not bring it up, and there is no sign at the counter or card in the bag.
- It is slower than the website. A forced account before the guest can see the menu loses people.
- The menu is out of date. An app run separately from the register shows items you sold out of.
- Nothing happens after install. No rewards, no reorder button, no notifications worth reading.
- Too many notifications. Guests turn them off or delete the app.
Almost every one of these is an operations problem, not a technology problem.
How do push notifications compare with SMS?
Push notifications are free to send and reach only people who installed the app and allowed notifications. Text messages cost money per message and reach anyone who gave you their number and their consent.
| Push notification | Text message (SMS) | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost per message | None | A per-message cost |
| Who you can reach | App users who allowed notifications | Anyone who opted in with a phone number |
| Permission | The phone asks the user to allow notifications | You must have the customer's consent to send marketing texts |
| Best for | Order status, rewards, offers to regulars | Time-sensitive offers, order updates, guests without the app |
Use both. Send order updates through whichever the guest has, keep marketing messages infrequent on each, and make it easy to opt out. Marketing texts are regulated, so collect consent properly. This is general information, not legal advice.
Do customers need to download an app to join a restaurant loyalty program?
No. A loyalty program can run on a phone number or an email address, with points earned at the register and online. An app makes the program more visible, since guests can see their points and rewards, but requiring a download to join will cut sign-ups. The better setup lets a guest join at the counter in seconds and discover the app later. Our loyalty programs guide covers the structures that work.
How do I get customers to download it?
Get downloads by asking at the moment a guest is already ordering, and by giving a concrete reason.
- An offer on the first app order. A free side or a few dollars off beats a general discount.
- A QR code where people wait. At the counter, on the pickup shelf, on table cards.
- A card in every bag, especially delivery-app bags, where the marketplace's rules allow it.
- A banner on your website and a link in your order confirmation emails and texts.
- Staff who mention it. One sentence at the register does more than any poster.
- Rewards that are easier in the app. Show the points balance and the next reward.
Then measure: downloads, first orders, and second orders. The second order is the one that tells you the app is working.
What features matter most?
The features that matter are the ones that make a repeat order faster.
- Reorder a past order in a couple of taps
- Saved payment and addresses
- Loyalty points and rewards visible on the first screen
- Order status notifications
- Coupons and gift cards that work in the app as they do in store
- The same menu as the register, including sold-out items
- Pickup and delivery in one flow
Features that rarely matter: games, social feeds and anything that needs its own content schedule.
Where RestauNax fits
A branded restaurant app for iOS and Android is part of the RestauNax base plan at $99/month per location, month-to-month, with 0% commission and card payments at 2.9% + $0.30. It is listed under your restaurant's name and icon, and it shows the same menu as your website and register, so there is one menu, one kitchen queue and one customer list. Loyalty points, coupons and gift cards work in the app, and guests get order status notifications. The plan also includes the ordering website, so you do not choose between the two. Book a free demo to see both.
Frequently Asked Questions
When is a restaurant app a waste of time?
When guests visit rarely, when nearly all sales are dine-in, or when nobody on the team will promote it. In those cases a fast mobile website with online ordering does the job.
Should I use a digital loyalty app or physical punch cards?
Digital, in most cases. A punch card cannot tell you who your regulars are or let you contact them. A digital program tied to a phone number records visits and lets you send an offer when a guest has not been in for a while.
What should a small restaurant consider before investing in a loyalty app?
Check how often guests return, whether the app shares a menu and customer list with your register, what it costs per month and per year, who owns the customer data, and what happens to the app if you cancel.
How much does a restaurant app cost?
The app-store accounts cost $99 a year for Apple and a one-time $25 for Google Play. The app itself ranges from part of a software plan to a large custom project. Ask what is included and who pays the store fees.
Is a mobile website enough for a small restaurant?
For many, yes. If your site loads fast on a phone, shows the menu as text and takes orders and payment, you have covered first-time customers. Add an app when repeat ordering becomes a large share of sales.
Can a restaurant have an app without a POS?
Yes, but the app then has its own menu and its own orders to manage. An app that shares one menu with the register avoids double entry and out-of-date items.
Tags:
About the Author
RestauNax
The team building RestauNax, writing about restaurant technology and the real cost of third-party delivery.