RestauNax Logo
Home FoodPricingAffiliate
Back to all platform comparisons
General E-Commerce

Etsy Alternative for Home Bakers: RestauNax vs Etsy

Etsy is a marketplace with fees on every sale. RestauNax is your own ordering website for $4.99/month with 0% commission.

8 min read

Prices checked Nov 14, 2026

Table of Contents
  • Introduction

  • How RestauNax Differs

  • Comparison Table

  • Pricing Breakdown

  • Which One Fits

  • Switching Guide

  • FAQs

The best Etsy alternative for home bakers depends on where your customers come from. Etsy brings shoppers and charges fees on every sale. RestauNax's Home Food plan is your own ordering website for $4.99/month with 0% commission on all orders and card processing of 2.9% + 30¢ on every card payment, online or in person, and it suits bakers who sell to local, repeat customers. Etsy's real strength is one RestauNax does not have: a marketplace that, in Etsy's words, connects people looking for unique goods with independent sellers around the world. If strangers finding you is the point, Etsy does that and we do not. The difference is the model. On Etsy you pay $0.20 per listing, a 6.5% transaction fee on the order total, including what you charge for shipping and gift wrap, and payment processing of 3% + $0.25 per order through Etsy Payments (US bank account), taken on the sale total including shipping and sales tax (Etsy Help Center, checked 2026-11-14), and the buyer orders on Etsy, inside Etsy's rules. On RestauNax the customer orders on your own website, the monthly price is flat, and each order adds that customer to a list that is yours. There is also a legal point that matters more for food than for crafts: in most states a cottage food law covers sales inside that state only, and many require the food to be handed over in person. A marketplace built around shipping to buyers anywhere can be a poor fit for food that cannot legally leave your state. This is general information, not legal advice. Confirm the rules with your state agency before you sell.

How RestauNax Differs from Etsy

Can You Sell Food on Etsy?

Yes, Etsy has food listings, but following food law is your job, not Etsy's. Etsy's Help Center says it does not require a business license, and that "you're required to follow any laws that apply to you as a small business selling online". Its Prohibited Items Policy covers "highly regulated items", and Etsy's House Rules include a page titled "Food and Edible Items". Etsy's site refused our direct request for that page on 2026-11-14, so we do not quote it: read it on Etsy before you list. Your state's cottage food law still decides what you may make at home, how it must be labeled, and whether you may ship it at all.

What Fees Do Etsy and Others Charge?

Etsy has no monthly fee on a standard shop. It charges $0.20 per listing, a 6.5% transaction fee on the order total, including what you charge for shipping and gift wrap, and payment processing of 3% + $0.25 per order through Etsy Payments (US bank account), taken on the sale total including shipping and sales tax. On a $30 order with no shipping charge that is $3.30. Optional Etsy Plus is $10/month. Among platforms made for home food sellers, Hotplate has no monthly fee and charges 5% + $0.55 per order, shown to the customer at checkout by default; the seller can choose to absorb it; Bakesy is $9.99 or $17.99/mo; Homegrown is $12.50/mo, or $10/mo billed annually ($120/year); RestauNax is $4.99/month with 0% commission on all orders. Card processing on RestauNax is 2.9% + 30¢ on every card payment, online or in person.

When Does Etsy's Offsite Ads Fee Apply?

Offsite Ads: 15% of the order total on orders that come from an Offsite Ad click (12% for shops that have made $10,000 or more in any 365-day period), never more than $100 per order. Shops that have never made $10,000 in any 365-day period are enrolled automatically but can opt out; from $10,000 participation is required for the lifetime of the shop. Etsy charges it only when a shopper clicks one of those ads and buys from your shop within 30 days. On a $30 order at the 15% rate that is $4.50 on top of the other fees. RestauNax has no advertising fee, and it also does not advertise your products for you.

Whose Customer Is It?

On Etsy the buyer shops with an Etsy account, on Etsy's site, next to other sellers' listings, and how you may contact that buyer afterwards is set by Etsy's policies. On RestauNax the customer orders on your own website, and every order adds them and their order history to your own customer list. One menu, one order list, one customer list and one login, all under your name.

Does a Shipping Marketplace Fit Cottage Food?

Often not. A cottage food law is a state exemption, so in most states it covers sales to customers inside that state, and many states require pickup or delivery by you in person. Rules on shipping by carrier differ from state to state. Etsy is built around shipping orders to buyers wherever they are, so it is up to the seller to make sure each order is one the law allows. Check your state in our cottage food law guides (restaunax.com/home-food-business/guides) and the guide to shipping cottage food across state lines (restaunax.com/home-food-business/guides/shipping-across-state-lines). The Home Food plan is built around local pre-orders and pickup. This is general information, not legal advice. Confirm the rules with your state agency before you sell.

Feature Comparison

Feature
RestauNax
$4.99/mo
Etsy
Monthly Price

$4.99/month

No monthly fee ($10/mo for optional Etsy Plus)

Commission or Transaction Fee

0%

6.5% transaction fee on the order total, including what you charge for shipping and gift wrap

Listing Fee

None

$0.20 per listing; a listing lasts 4 months

Card processing

2.9% + 30¢ on every card payment, online or in person

3% + $0.25 per order through Etsy Payments (US bank account), taken on the sale total including shipping and sales tax

Advertising Fee

None

Offsite Ads: 15% of the order total on orders that come from an Offsite Ad click (12% for shops that have made $10,000 or more in any 365-day period), never more than $100 per order

Set-Up Fee

No setup fee

A one-time fee that varies by location; Etsy publishes no figure

Marketplace of Shoppers

Yes. Shoppers already browsing Etsy can find you

Where Customers Order

Your own website

Your shop page on Etsy

Customer List

Every order adds the customer to your own list

Not verified

Pre-Orders with a Pickup Time

Not verified

Deposits on Custom Orders

Not verified

Contract and trial

Month to month; no trial period, book a demo first

Etsy Plus can be cancelled anytime

Monthly Price

RestauNax

$4.99/month

Etsy

No monthly fee ($10/mo for optional Etsy Plus)

Commission or Transaction Fee

RestauNax

0%

Etsy

6.5% transaction fee on the order total, including what you charge for shipping and gift wrap

Listing Fee

RestauNax

None

Etsy

$0.20 per listing; a listing lasts 4 months

Card processing

RestauNax

2.9% + 30¢ on every card payment, online or in person

Etsy

3% + $0.25 per order through Etsy Payments (US bank account), taken on the sale total including shipping and sales tax

Advertising Fee

RestauNax

None

Etsy

Offsite Ads: 15% of the order total on orders that come from an Offsite Ad click (12% for shops that have made $10,000 or more in any 365-day period), never more than $100 per order

Set-Up Fee

RestauNax

No setup fee

Etsy

A one-time fee that varies by location; Etsy publishes no figure

Marketplace of Shoppers

RestauNax

Etsy

Yes. Shoppers already browsing Etsy can find you

Where Customers Order

RestauNax

Your own website

Etsy

Your shop page on Etsy

Customer List

RestauNax

Every order adds the customer to your own list

Etsy

Not verified

Pre-Orders with a Pickup Time

RestauNax

Etsy

Not verified

Deposits on Custom Orders

RestauNax

Etsy

Not verified

Contract and trial

RestauNax

Month to month; no trial period, book a demo first

Etsy

Etsy Plus can be cancelled anytime

Prices as published by each vendor, checked November 14, 2026. Sources: Etsy. “Not verified” means we could not confirm it from the vendor's page, not that the vendor lacks it.

Pricing Breakdown

Etsy

Transaction fee: 6.5% transaction fee on the order total, including what you charge for shipping and gift wrap
Etsy Standard — $0/month
  • no subscription fee; you pay per listing and per sale

Etsy Plus — $10/month
  • optional; includes 15 listing credits and $5 in Etsy Ads credit each month

Fees and notes

Listing fee: $0.20 per listing, charged whether or not the item sells; a listing lasts 4 months

Payment processing: 3% + $0.25 per order through Etsy Payments (US bank account), taken on the sale total including shipping and sales tax

Offsite Ads: 15% of the order total on orders that come from an Offsite Ad click (12% for shops that have made $10,000 or more in any 365-day period), never more than $100 per order

Shops that have never made $10,000 in any 365-day period are enrolled automatically but can opt out; from $10,000 participation is required for the lifetime of the shop

Set-up fee: Etsy charges a one-time set-up fee when you open a shop and says the cost varies by location. It publishes no figure, so we state none.

RestauNax

Home-food plan

$4.99/month

0% commission on all orders; card processing 2.9% + 30¢ on every card payment, online or in person
  • Your own website with an online menu: photos, descriptions, sizes and prices

  • Online ordering with card payment at checkout

  • Pre-orders: customers order ahead and pick a pickup time, with a minimum lead time you set

  • Deposits when a custom order is placed

  • Sold-out and stop-ordering switches you control

  • A customer list of your own, built from every order

From 3 orders of $30 a month, RestauNax costs less in fees. Below that, Etsy does.

Fees per month at three sales levels. 2 orders ($60 in sales): Etsy $6.60, RestauNax $7.33, so Etsy is $0.73 cheaper. 20 orders ($600 in sales): Etsy $66, RestauNax $28.39, so RestauNax is $37.61 cheaper. 60 orders ($1800 in sales): Etsy $198, RestauNax $75.19, so RestauNax is $122.81 cheaper. Etsy's cost on a $30 order is $0.20 listing fee + $1.95 transaction fee + $1.15 payment processing = $3.30. RestauNax's is $4.99/month plus $1.17 card processing per order. Assumptions: every order is one $30 item from one listing, the customer collects it so no shipping is charged, no order comes from an Offsite Ad, sales tax is left out, and the shop is a standard Etsy shop without Etsy Plus. An order that comes from an Offsite Ad costs a further $4.50 on Etsy. The comparison is fees only: Etsy's fees also buy you a place in front of its shoppers, which RestauNax does not provide.

Etsy or RestauNax: Which One Fits

Etsy Is the Better Choice for Being Found

Etsy puts your listing in front of people who are already shopping there, and it advertises listings on search engines and social sites. RestauNax has no marketplace. If you have no customers yet and your food can legally be shipped, Etsy is the stronger place to start.

Etsy Is the Cheaper Choice at Very Low Volume

With no monthly fee, Etsy costs less when you sell very little. At 2 orders of $30 a month, Etsy's fees are $6.60 against $7.33 on RestauNax. In a month with no sales, Etsy costs only your listing fees and RestauNax still costs $4.99/month.

RestauNax Costs Less in Fees Once You Sell Regularly

From 3 orders of $30 a month the flat price is lower. At 20 orders, Etsy's fees are $66 and RestauNax is $28.39; at 60 orders, $198 and $75.19. Assumptions: every order is one $30 item from one listing, the customer collects it so no shipping is charged, no order comes from an Offsite Ad, sales tax is left out, and the shop is a standard Etsy shop without Etsy Plus.

RestauNax Fits Local, Repeat Orders

If your customers are neighbors, market regulars and people who order a cake every birthday, they do not need a marketplace to find you. They need a menu, a pickup time and a way to pay. The Home Food plan gives you an online menu, pre-orders with a lead time you set, card payments, deposits on custom orders and your own customer list.

Shipping Rules Come First

Before choosing either one, find out whether your state lets a cottage food seller ship by carrier at all, and where to. Most states that allow it limit it to customers inside the state. See restaunax.com/home-food-business/guides/shipping-across-state-lines. This is general information, not legal advice. Confirm the rules with your state agency before you sell.

You Can Use Both

You can keep an Etsy shop for products that can legally be shipped and for being discovered, and send local and repeat customers to your own site, where there is no fee per sale beyond card processing.

How Do You Move Customers Off a Marketplace?

1
Read the Marketplace's Rules First

You move customers by giving them a reason and a place to order from you directly, not by copying a buyer list. Etsy's policies set how you may use buyer information, so read its seller policy before you contact anyone, and do not assume order details can be used for marketing.

2
Build Your Own Store

Send us your products, prices, options and photos. We build your RestauNax store from the content you give us. Book a free demo to start; timing is confirmed on the call.

3
Put Your Own Address Where Customers Already Look

Your social bios, your stall sign, your business card and the label or card that goes out with each order you hand over. Check the marketplace's rules on what may go inside a marketplace order.

4
Take Local and Repeat Orders on Your Site

Point pickup customers, market regulars and custom-order requests to your own menu. Each order there adds the customer to your own list.

5
Keep the Marketplace for Discovery if It Pays

You do not have to close an Etsy shop. Compare what it brings in new buyers with what it costs in fees, and decide from your own numbers.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes. Etsy has food listings and its House Rules include a "Food and Edible Items" page. Etsy's Help Center says it does not require a business license but that sellers are "required to follow any laws that apply to you as a small business selling online". So the legal work is yours: your state's cottage food law decides what you can make at home, how it is labeled and whether it can be shipped. We could not open Etsy's food policy page directly on 2026-11-14, so read it on Etsy before you list.

As published in Etsy's Help Center and checked on 2026-11-14: $0.20 per listing, a 6.5% transaction fee on the order total, including what you charge for shipping and gift wrap, and payment processing of 3% + $0.25 per order through Etsy Payments (US bank account), taken on the sale total including shipping and sales tax. Offsite Ads: 15% of the order total on orders that come from an Offsite Ad click (12% for shops that have made $10,000 or more in any 365-day period), never more than $100 per order. Etsy Plus is an optional $10/month. For comparison, Hotplate charges 5% + $0.55 per order, shown to the customer at checkout by default; the seller can choose to absorb it, Bakesy is $9.99 or $17.99/mo, Homegrown is $12.50/mo, or $10/mo billed annually ($120/year) and RestauNax is $4.99/month with 0% commission on all orders; card processing on RestauNax is 2.9% + 30¢ on every card payment, online or in person.

It depends on how much you sell. On a $30 order with no shipping charge, Etsy's listing, transaction and processing fees come to $3.30; RestauNax's card processing comes to $1.17, plus $4.99/month for the plan. 2 orders ($60 in sales): Etsy $6.60, RestauNax $7.33, so Etsy is $0.73 cheaper. 20 orders ($600 in sales): Etsy $66, RestauNax $28.39, so RestauNax is $37.61 cheaper. 60 orders ($1800 in sales): Etsy $198, RestauNax $75.19, so RestauNax is $122.81 cheaper. From 3 such orders a month RestauNax costs less. Assumptions: every order is one $30 item from one listing, the customer collects it so no shipping is charged, no order comes from an Offsite Ad, sales tax is left out, and the shop is a standard Etsy shop without Etsy Plus. Etsy's fees also bring you shoppers; RestauNax has no marketplace.

Only for larger shops. Shops that have never made $10,000 in any 365-day period are enrolled automatically but can opt out; from $10,000 participation is required for the lifetime of the shop. The fee itself: 15% of the order total on orders that come from an Offsite Ad click (12% for shops that have made $10,000 or more in any 365-day period), never more than $100 per order.

Usually not under a cottage food law. A cottage food law is a state exemption, so it generally covers sales inside that state, and many states require the food to be picked up or delivered by you in person. Selling on Etsy does not change that. Check your state in our cottage food law guides and the guide to shipping cottage food across state lines. This is general information, not legal advice. Confirm the rules with your state agency before you sell.

Texas allows online sales only in a specific way. The Texas Department of State Health Services says cottage food may be sold online when the consumer buys it online from the operator and the operator, an employee or a household member personally delivers it to the consumer (DSHS cottage food page, checked 2026-11-14). An order sent to a buyer by a parcel carrier does not match that. DSHS's page does not address marketplaces by name, and whether a particular product such as a dry drink mix qualifies is a separate question, so ask DSHS or your local health department. This is general information, not legal advice. Confirm the rules with your state agency before you sell.

Etsy is a general marketplace for handmade goods, not a food ordering tool. Platforms made for home food sellers include Bakesy ($9.99 or $17.99/mo; a shop website, order forms and invoices for home bakers), Hotplate (no monthly fee; built for timed drops and pre-orders), Homegrown ($12.50/mo, or $10/mo billed annually ($120/year); a local marketplace of nearby vendors) and RestauNax's Home Food plan ($4.99/month; your own website with an online menu, pre-orders, card payments, deposits and a customer list). None of them changes what your state's law allows.

Give them a place to order from you directly and tell them about it where they already see you: your social bios, your market stall, your business card and your packaging. Take local and repeat orders on your own site so each one adds to your own customer list. Read the marketplace's policy on using buyer information before contacting past buyers, and keep the marketplace shop if it still brings you new customers.

No. The two do different jobs. Etsy puts shippable products in front of its shoppers; a RestauNax store takes orders from customers who already know you, for $4.99/month with 0% commission on all orders. Card processing is 2.9% + 30¢ on every card payment, online or in person. There is no free trial; book a free demo to see it first.

Compare RestauNax to Other Home Food Platforms


About RestauNax for Home Food Businesses

RestauNax offers a $4.99/month platform for home food businesses, cottage food operators, home bakers, and small food makers. The platform includes a professional website, online ordering, shipping tools (FedEx/USPS/UPS), Stripe payment processing, customer directory, multi-language support, and analytics — all with zero commission fees. What you may sell from a home kitchen, and whether you may ship it, depends on your state's cottage food law; selling across state lines generally needs a licensed commercial kitchen.

See RestauNax for Home Food — $4.99/month

0% commission on all orders. Card processing is 2.9% + $0.30 per payment. Book a free demo and we will walk through your menu and how you sell.